^^YUP.
It’s been a while since I shared a Stitch Fix box! Over the years, I have bought some pieces from Stitch Fix that I love and wear over and over and over, and a few things that I thought I would love but don’t wear that much (or at all, gulp). Plus, in an effort to work on my curated, functional wardrobe, I’m trying to be really picky about what I let into my closet.
When shopping, I used to ask myself, “Do I like it and does it fit well?”
Now I am asking myself this question: “Thinking back on the past year, where would I have worn this and would I have liked this more than what I did wear.”
This mentality really forces me not only to imagine myself wearing the clothing in public to an event, but it also makes me consider what I might already have that I would choose to wear instead. I tend to wear favorites over and over again, and they often win over something that I like, but like just a little less for whatever reason (comfort is one of the biggest reasons!).
So here’s what came in my latest Stitch Fix box, and what I decided to keep and what I sent back! (And next time I promise to have a friend take some better photos in natural light! My closet is no fun for photography. Also my apologies as I don’t have the names of the clothes anymore!)
First up, this beautiful purse! I loved the rosey pink, the soft leather, and the interior pattern, BUT I have a coral purse – which I got from Stitch Fix a year ago – that I love and use, so I considered this a duplicate to something I already own (although it really is quite different in style.)
Very cute though! Matched my Apple Watch ; )
These jeans are by Liverpool, who made one of my favorite pairs of jeans that I got from SF a while ago. The ones I have are high waisted, so I love that they don’t sag down. These jeans fit me like I glove on first try, but I have learned that with jeans you really have to dance around the room and move in them to know if they are going to stay put. I can’t stand sagging jeans that need to be pulled up by the belt loops each time I stand up, and, ultimately, that’s what these did. They were just a little too stretchy! A bummer, because once in place I loved the fit. Sent ’em on back. Can anyone recommend some jeans that stay put? I think I just need to steer away from stretchy jeans to find them.
This top was flowy and cute, but I wasn’t wild about the maroon color. I also thought it made me look pregnant because it poofed out in just that spot, and I don’t want those kinds of rumors starting now, do I!
This dress – the Renay Cold Shoulder Dress – was the one piece I kept! It met my criteria of practical (long sleeves that went all the way down so winter-appropriate), comfortable, and cute.
I loved the split sleeves, and that I could dress it up or make it more casual as well.
This black top is an old Stitch Fix purchase. I love the little sheer criss-cross ruffle on the bottom. My necklace is Stella and Dot, the New Moon Necklace.
And finally, this dress was cute in hand and I liked the lace detail, but its shape did nothing for my figure. Sent ‘er back.
I just wrote this note to my stylist for my next fix: “I am on the hunt for super comfortable sweatshirts, tunics, fleece-lined things, and sweaters!” LOL – winter much?!
She should write back, “Now Kath, we are not in the sweatpants and fleece market. We are here to get you out of those!”
But I did get a few more keepers in my next box –
This tunic and the LEGGINGS! These are smooth, compressiony leggings, and they are my new favorites to wear under clothes (not to the gym).
This dress just seemed like such a classic, all-around solid piece. And I love me some black.
And this cardigan came in the same box and looked great with the dress! Love the lace detail, length, and that it’s pretty fitted on my body. I always need cardigans to keep warm in the spring and fall.
What has been your favorite Stitch Fix piece to date? Mine is either the purse that I mentioned above, my navy blue cargo jacket, or one of my two favorite pairs of jeans.
Melissa says
I love the purse and leggings! The purse is a perfect color that would pair well with mostly anything and black leggings is a go-to staple!
Jen says
What you kept was perfect! Loved the polka dot dress, so flattering and comfy looking, and the floral dress seems so you.
JS says
Love that dress too. we find it?
Charmaine Ng | Architecture & Lifestyle Blog says
The pieces they sent really suit you!
Charmaine Ng | Architecture & Lifestyle Blog
http://charmainenyw.com
KathEats says
Thanks!
Kelli @ Hungry Hobby says
Mine is either my olive purse or any shirt I’ve ever bought, ha ha I hate shopping so Stitchfix is my life!
Allison says
You look so happy, relaxed, and confident these days!!!
KathEats says
Thank you 🙂
Christina @ montessoriishmom.com says
I love that polka dot dress! I am the same way with always choosing favorites, I need to use the same criteria of whether I already have something I would wear instead, great idea.
Jill says
Kath, that polka-dot dress at the end is amazing. I could see wearing it to work, or out for cocktails. Super cute and flattering. Nice pick.
KathEats says
thanks!
Tonya says
Last pic: nice. legs. BRAAAWWRR!
LOL!
KathEats says
LOL!
Sam @ Hygge Wellness says
I love all of the pieces you chose to keep! So cute. Love Stitch Fix!
Aimee says
Ooh I actually love that maroon top! I know what you mean about the jeans. I kept a very expensive pair stitch fix sent me, but hardly wear them now because I have to constantly pull then up :/ funny, probably my favorite pair of jeans is actually from Wal-Mart that I had to buy on the fly! $28 ha ha
Susan says
Love the dresses in this post!
My favourite jeans are made by Paige denim. I find especially the high rise ones do not need to be pulled up, they fit beautifully and are great quality.
KathEats says
Thanks! I like the high rise style too 🙂
Izzy | pinch of delight says
I love the bag – so cute and will go with everything! x
Izzy |https://pinchofdelight.wordpress.com
Taryn says
Favorite jeans I own are from Banana Republic outlet. A bit higher waisted, but very minimal “pulling them up every time I stand up.” I hate shopping for jeans! I did get the new Athleta catalogue in the mail yesterday and was drooling over EVERYTHING!
KathEats says
Ugh me too! I was next to the store on Monday and did not allow myself to go inside since my clothing spending was maxed for the month. Maybe next month : )
Kimberly says
The green dress is so cute on you and I think the maroon top looks great! It doesn’t make you look pregnant at all! Love the polka dot dress, too.
Kelsey @ So Much Life says
Hmm, I had the same issue with my liverpool jeans from stitch fix. I can’t stand a saggy butt on my jeans, haha!
Michelle says
I love Stitch Fix. I tend to buy basically the same things again and again so SF is a great way to get variety in my wardrobe. I have put my membership on hold for the time being until I pay off some debt but I will definitely be signing up again!
Lauren says
You look great! Would you mind sharing the brand of the leggings? I have a hard time finding non-workout leggings that fit well and are not transparent. Thanks 🙂
KathEats says
They’re the Kendrick Legging
Sally says
I actually really love that maroon top on you too! My favorite jeans are actually from Loft – the high rise modern skinny fit. They’re pretty high quality, yet still affordable, and they stay up!
Laurie says
I have the same black cardigan from Stitch Fix. It’s super cute! My favorite item they have sent me so far is a black pair of Moto leggings with “pleather” detail. I’m wearing them right now…like…right now! They are warm and cozy and give me a teaspoon of street cred.
Stitch Fix…love them…
Faith says
I also like the maroon top on you. Super cute. But, you are the one who has to wear it. 🙂 Also, that polka dot dress is perfect!
Carrie says
LOVE that black dress on you. It looks amazing!!!!!
KathEats says
Thank you!
Jeanie says
I do not Stitch Fix because I love shopping too much and am pretty picky. Just wanted to let you know that AG jeans are awesome and don’t bag out. They are very pricey, but I’ve been lucky enough to get a couple pairs on clearance at Nordstrom Rack and one at Marshall’s. Joe’s jeans are good as well, but buy them tight ’cause they will bag a little after they’re worn for a while.
Jolene (www.everydayfoodie.ca) says
What a neat company! I wonder if something like that is available in Canada …
Anyway, does everything they send always fit? So many brands of pants fit differently, etc. even if they are the same size, and it’s often difficult to judge by size, that’s why I’m wondering.
KathEats says
So I have never been one to be able to walk into a store and put on a pair of pants. Sizes vary so much that my size in one store I couldn’t get over my calves in another, but in years of Stitch Fix, I have only had that happen maybe once?? I really have no idea why! But most things fit – it’s just a matter of it they are flattering and if I like them
Lois says
I liked the maroon top, actually. It’s obvious there’s not a preg belly under it though (refuse to use the term baby bump. Hate it.) The print dress isn’t really flattering though. The print is nice, but the shape does nothing for you. (I’m short too, 5′), and too much volume is not our friend. Maybe have top part taken in a bit and add a belt? You should seek out more teal. That is quite nice with your coloring.
The Many Thoughts of a Reader says
Love both of the dresses and the leggings! I have a box coming and I’m hopeful!
Nikki says
You have such gorgeous hair!
KathEats says
Thanks! It was day old in a lot of these pics – eek!
Jenny says
Glad you’re still finding success with StitchFix. I didn’t like anything in my last 2 fixes at all. I’ve had to write them off, unfortunately. I so enjoyed them when they first started. 😐
Angela says
If you ever wear dress pants, you need to request the Emer pants from SF. They are the best dress pants I’ve ever owned! I can’t get enough of them!
debbie says
I love the polka dot dress and cardigan. I also love your shoes are they Toms ?
KathEats says
Yes! So comfortable
Taylor says
The maroon top was way more flattering than that colorful dress or the tunic you kept! Not a fan of the shape of the cardigan either 🙂 but I guess that’s why we are all different. The polka-dot dress is fab!